Why this checklist existsThe category got noisy. Buyers got burned.
Between January 2024 and April 2026, the number of vendors marketing themselves as AI medical coding platforms more than tripled. The category split into three honest tiers and one dishonest one. The honest tiers are full autonomous coding on tuned specialties, AI-assisted coder workflows, and natural-language search over a code book. The dishonest tier is a generic large language model with a coding wrapper, sold as autonomous, with no audit trail, no V28 map, and no path to RADV defensibility. Buyers signed contracts in the first two quarters of 2025 expecting tier-one and got tier-four. The contracts are still being unwound.
This article is the checklist we wish those buyers had used. Twelve features. Every one of them is a hard yes or no in a real demo. None of them is a marketing claim. None of them is something a vendor can answer with a slide. If a vendor cannot demonstrate a feature on your own chart sample, the feature does not exist.
A serious AI coding platform is not a model. It is a model, plus a current code map, plus an audit trail, plus a coder review path, plus a payer rule library, plus an EHR integration. Five out of six is not the product. All six is the product.